J2Ski logo J2Ski logo
Login Forum Search Recent Forums

Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not

Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not

Login
To Create or Answer a Topic

Started by Flatbadger in Ski Hardware - 34 Replies

J2Ski

Flatbadger
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

Decision Made!

I am going to join the ranks of the lid wearers. There is no hard evidence for me to wear one but there is also no reason for me not to wear one either.

Wearing a helmet will not increase my attitude to risk...... my attitude to risk is constrained by my skiing ability & No ACL or Cartlidge in my right knee

I am wearing a helmet for those instances where you may get dumped on your arse by someone else who hasn't had the care and responsibility for those piste users on the downslope

I realise that the chance of death is low 1 in 1,006,000 ski days and the chance of a head injury is 1:400,000 ski days and that a helmet is unlikely to prevent this type of injury at normal ski speeds and if the head impacts the ground at over 20 mph

I have purchase a MIPS helmet as this is meant to be better in preventing rotational injuries of the spine and neck which are higher in number than head injuries.

I got a deal on the Helmet - List price £110 - Paid £83

Thanks to everyone that chipped in on this thread

Avoriaz for me on the Jan 20th!

Enjoy the snow guys!

Gareth Fair
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

Many years ago I had a bad fall and banged my head so now I won't ski without one.
It may be great marketing but I've a wife and kids at home so safety is a must for me.
When in doubt?....Flat out.

Andymol2
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

Blind studies on the effectiveness of helmets with real people are going to be limited. Ethical approval for real life crash test skiers might prove difficult.

At the extremes of impact they will be irrelevant.
Moderate impact with be reduced - hopefully by enough to reduce life changing injuries into something less severe.
Skull cracking by impact with pointed rocks may also be prevented.
Cuts and scrapes may well be reduced as the helmet should stay on when a woolly hat might not!

Whether that is enough to justify wearing one is an individual choice.
The stats from motorcycle accidents suggest they make a difference but social skiing is vastly less dangerous than riding a motorcycle on the road so reducing the risk may not translate into big numbers of lives saved.
Andy M

Brucie
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

As I said. Personal choice. You have chosen to pay £83 for a piece of brightly coloured plastic that costs a 'cool' sounding company pennies to produce in an Asian sweat shop.
If it makes you feel better, then so be it.
"Better to remain reticent and have people think one is an idiot, than to open ones mouth and remove all doubt"

Brucie
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

As I said. Personal choice. You have chosen to pay £83 for a piece of brightly coloured plastic that costs a 'cool' sounding company pennies to produce in an Asian sweat shop.
If it makes you feel better, then so be it.
"Better to remain reticent and have people think one is an idiot, than to open ones mouth and remove all doubt"

Iceman
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

Always happens on any debate on here - personal remarks that add zero value

The same is applicable for the majority of clothes and footwear you wear including ski gear - unless you make your own with knitting needles?!

He made a decision that suits him. What's up with that?
The Northern Monkey. Jan'23 Les Arcs

Bedrock barney
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

Well said Icy. :thumbup:

slippy slidey snow......me likey!

Brucie
reply to 'Canvassing opinion for helmet wearing or not'
posted Jan-2018

As I said, personal choice.I actually thought I was making a valid point about the evils of capitalism and the exploitation of third world workers. I know my opinion differs from you two. I still believe I have the right to express it.
Thanks for the reaction though. Love it!!!
"Better to remain reticent and have people think one is an idiot, than to open ones mouth and remove all doubt"

Edited 1 time. Last update at 12-Jan-2018

Topic last updated on 15-January-2018 at 00:19