J2Ski logo J2Ski logo
Login Forum Search Recent Forums

How do you explain the risks.

How do you explain the risks.

Login
To Create or Answer a Topic

Started by Vincentus in Beginning Skiing - 26 Replies

J2Ski

Freezywater
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

ise wrote:
freezywater wrote:
ise - we're all entitled to our opinions, it just happens that you're wrong. I DO live in a litigation culture, you may not but that was not my point and snowsports ARE classed as 'high-risk' and the premiums ARE higher, or do you also work in insurance part-time?


This is pretty simple to prove.

First, ski premiums are very low, it's a fact. How low? Less than 3€ a day (source: AXA Insurance, French ski Federation, l' ASSOCIATION TOURISTIQUE SPORTIVE et CULTURELLE des ADMINISTRATIONS FINANCIERES), that's what carte neige would cost in France for a day on the slopes, it's a perfect example as all other risk is stripped out, they're not covering having your skis stolen, flight delays, lost or delayed luggage that a policy with a ski holiday might cover, it's just cover for having an accident on or near the slopes.

In fact, that's expensive, you can have the whole season, regardless of how many days, for under 50€ by taking the annual ticket. (source: AXA Insurance, French ski Federation, l' ASSOCIATION TOURISTIQUE SPORTIVE et CULTURELLE des ADMINISTRATIONS FINANCIERES)

... but even that's expensive, you could have the whole year in the mountains in Switzerland, skiing, climbing, hiking, mountain biking, flying a parapente if you wished for 30.- chf. (source: air glaciers or REGA)

... but even that's expensive, as a mountain professional resident in Switzerland I pay only 20.- and they'll come and get me from anywhere in the world if I have an accident. (source: air glaciers or REGA, Swiss residency permit holders only, federally recognised mountaineering qualifications, member of recognised professional groups only)

... but even that's expensive, it's so low risk that as a leader, guide or ski instructor your household insurer in Switzerland will cover your first 6000.- chf of income professionally. (source: Zurich, Zuritel and others, "responsabilité civile", federally recognised mountaineering qualifications, member of recognised professional groups only)

Are snowsports high risk? Of course not, trencher already pointed this out. This is measured, recorded and logged, we know exactly, globally how much risk there is because adverse outcomes are recorded. We know there's fewer accidents per participant days in skiing than in football, rugby, cycling or, the very best known and most used example, horse riding. (I've provided this data and sources previously on J2SKI I believe)

You don't live in a litigation culture unless you personally chose to. Number of UK claims has risen by 3% in the last 5 years and numbers of personal injury claims are actually down. (source: Compensation Recovery Unit at the Department for Work and Pensions) The figures cherry picked by newspaper scare stories include motor claims and clinical negligence, if I were looking for something to worry about in the UK it would the underlying causes of the rise in clinical negligence claims and just who the national press is beholden to.


ise - thanks for the googling, very impressive, have saved this in readiness for snowboard holiday next year :lol: :wink:
I would have got away with it if it wasn't for those pesky kids!

Ise
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

freezywater wrote:
ise - thanks for the googling, very impressive, have saved this in readiness for snowboard holiday next year :lol: :wink:


why on earth would you think I need google? :roll: this is nothing other than first hand information.

Vincentus
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

Thats a lot of facts!
Thats a lot of data!
The risks are there in life, as we all know.
I will advocate the helmet for my girls peace of mind and let her enjoy
the subsequent rush of mastering the snow gradually with each lesson and trip.
I thank you all for the logic and the statistics.

Vince :D
Let it snow.

Vincentus
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

I went to the local Melbourne CBD ski shops today during lunch break. Great to see all the 09 ski
range in-store now, just adds to the excitement. Mentioned the quest for a womans helmet
to the staff in 2 stores. They admit they have increased orders from last year because of
the Richardson accident. I was told that similar incident happened in Germany? A politician
collided with another and killed him. The next day all helmets sold out in Germany?
Maybe an exaggeration, but it makes sense.
I won't tell daughter about that German story, in case i scare her off the mountain :roll:

Let it snow.

Pablo Escobar
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

Vincentus wrote:I went to the local Melbourne CBD ski shops today during lunch break. Great to see all the 09 ski
range in-store now, just adds to the excitement. Mentioned the quest for a womans helmet
to the staff in 2 stores. They admit they have increased orders from last year because of
the Richardson accident. I was told that similar incident happened in Germany? A politician
collided with another and killed him. The next day all helmets sold out in Germany?
Maybe an exaggeration, but it makes sense.
I won't tell daughter about that German story, in case i scare her off the mountain :roll:


Where are the ski shops in the CBD, in my time of wandering about I never came across any!

Vincentus
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

How long ago where you here?
In Elizabeth St near the camera stores crush, the store is Altitude.
Around the corner 50m away in Hardware Lane, Auski and Capitol 17.
Little Bourke St in between Altitude and Auski, there is Columbia,
Snowgum and Paddy Pallin. In the Commonwealth Bank Galleria we have
Helly Hansen and North Face. Actually bought some ski socks in Columbia.
Cheaper than last year! :mrgreen: Not all prices go up. :lol:
Let it snow.

Pablo Escobar
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

4 years this summer so things will have probably changed. Was staying on the corner of Little Bourke and Queen Street. I still owe a wee coffee shop called Crush (corner of Bourke and Hardware Ln I think) or something money for soup I failed to pay for

Vincentus
reply to 'How do you explain the risks.'
posted May-2009

Little Bourke and Queen?????????? :shock:
Auski have been there in Hardware Lane since 1949.
Most of those stores have been there more than 4 years.
I will check each store for your peace of mind. You must
have had a "Great Time" 8) here not to have stumbled
across these stores.
I work at QV just a 5mins walk away.
You are a Lad and legend )
Let it snow.

Topic last updated on 12-May-2009 at 14:00