J2Ski logo J2Ski logo
Login Forum Search Recent Forums

Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets

Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets

Login
To Create or Answer a Topic

Started by J2SkiNews in Ski News - 44 Replies

Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets

J2SkiNews posted Nov-2011



A new survey paid for by the Post Office has found that over half of skiers admit they rarely or never wear a helmet when on the slopes (51 per cent), despite the risk of serious injury.

The research released today by Post Office Travel Insurance Research was conducted for them by a company called Populus last month (October 2011) among 508 UK adults who have been on a skiing holiday within the last five years.

It found that the least likely to don a helmet are seasoned skiers, who have been on more than five skiing holidays in the last five years. Nearly all of them rarely or never wear a helmet (94 per cent) when on the slopes. In comparison first time skiers are savvier on the slopes with just under half wearing a helmet (49 per cent).

Over 55s were found to be the least likely to have worn a helmet on a skiing holiday (36 per cent), compared to over half (58 per cent) of 18 to 34 year olds who are more safety conscious.

'Never having considered wearing one' is the principle reason (48 per cent) why skiers have never worn a helmet. For just over a quarter, not seeing skiing or snowboarding as a sport where people wear helmets (27 per cent) and it being a habit not to wear one (27 per cent) are other reasons given for not wearing a helmet on the slopes. Over confidence is also a key reason for many not to protect themselves, with a quarter admitting they don't think they need one (25 per cent).

Three in five women think it is unfashionable to wear a helmet and believe it messes up their hair (15 per cent). Only 3% of men said they worried about how a helmet will make them look. Men are more likely to give in to bravado, shunning a helmet because they think they just don't need it (30 per cent).

Of those skiers who do wear a helmet, one in five (20 per cent) say they felt it was necessary as a result of either having an accident previously (10 per cent), suffering a serious head injury themselves (2 per cent) or a close friend or relative suffering a serious head injury (8 per cent).

For those who are planning to wear a helmet on their next skiing holiday, reports in the media of bad skiing accidents (48 per cent) and seeing more people wearing helmets on the slopes (43 per cent) are the key reasons why.

Dr Mike Langran, ski patrol doctor at CairnGorm Mountain in the Scottish Highlands and GP at the Aviemore Medical Practice said: "Helmets have been a hot topic in the snow-sports safety forum for many years now. I am a helmet wearer and would always recommend others to wear one too. There is good evidence to indicate that a helmet will protect you against many of the common injuries that the head is susceptible too when on the slopes, although the overall risk of injury remains low. A variety of recent studies have concluded that wearing a helmet may reduce your risk of head injury by up to 60%.

"Remember though, wearing a helmet does not make you invincible! If you do buy a helmet make sure it fits properly and is designed for snow sports by meeting one or more of the following standards - ASTM F2040, Snell RS98 or CEN 1077."

"Although we don't insist our customers wear a helmet on the slopes, it is something that we strongly recommend." Said Sarah Munro, Head of Travel Insurance at the Post Office. "Whilst wearing a helmet doesn't make you immune to injury, it does add another layer of protection – so you can relax and enjoy your holiday knowing you've done everything you can to be as safe as possible. Making sure you have travel insurance that specifically covers winter sports is another precaution that will be invaluable should you have an accident."
www  The Snow Hunter

Edited 2 times. Last update at 22-Nov-2011

Dave Mac
reply to 'Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets'
posted Nov-2011

Some of the statistics are a bit odd, (94%/36%), but I would be this down to a very low statistical group number.
Many countries and ski schools have, for a number of years, insisted on young skiers wearing helmets. Thus what they did when they were 14 years old, comes naturally when they are 20 years old. Within one generation, the statistics will reverse.

Trencher
reply to 'Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets'
posted Nov-2011

and the survey was of people who had skied in the last five years - a lot has changed in that time. Someone who last skied three years ago is not representative of current trends.
because I'm so inclined .....

Edited 1 time. Last update at 23-Nov-2011

J2SkiNews
reply to 'Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets'
posted Nov-2011

I thought exactly that. Those stats were buried at the end of the press release in small print so I put them up at the start
www  The Snow Hunter

Daved
reply to 'Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets'
posted Nov-2011

The reporting is a mite biased too..

one would like to know... what are the statistics for serious Head injuries compared to other injuries sustained on the slopes

Admin
reply to 'Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets'
posted Nov-2011

I think the words "Unbelievable" or "Flawed" need to be inserted at the beginning of this thread title Mr News Editor!

Although some of the findings are sound, that headline statistic is just plain wrong. In recent years, in the groups I've skied with, I reckon helmet wearers account for 75%+ and the percentage (IMHO) appears to increase with experience.

In fact, the Doctor quoted in the above article (Mike Langran is the ski patrol doctor at CairnGorm) says exactly that on his website...

According to the 2009/10 NSAA National Demographic Study 57% of US skiers and boarders wore a helmet (up from 25% in 2002/03 and a 9% rise on the previous year)
...
- Helmet usage increases with ability level - 26% of beginners wore a helmet compared to 55% of advanced riders.

In Switzerland, about 80% of skiers and boarders wear helmets now. In Scotland, helmet usage has also increased but to lower levels - approx 40% of the total population. However, about 70% of those aged less than 16 years now wear a helmet.


daved wrote:what are the statistics for serious Head injuries compared to other injuries sustained on the slopes


Mike Langran's excellent website is one of the best sources of stats, and references various large-scale and long-term studies.

Start here - www.ski-injury.com/prevention/helmet
The Admin Man

Daved
reply to 'Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets'
posted Nov-2011

Interesting report...it does say that ..if you want to read it that way...that more than 50% of ski/board fatalities were wearing a helmet so therefore it must be more risky to wear one as less than 100% of skiers/boarders wear one.

"Shealy et al's 2008 publication concludes that "the salutary effect [of helmet usage] was limited to the less serious head injuries, such as scalp lacerations and mild concussions. No significant effect was noted for the more serious head injuries such as concussions more severe than mild, closed head injury, skull fracture and death due to head injury."

"But even taking this 43% rate coupled with the highest injury rate gives a rate for head injury of 2.4 per 1000 skier days - really very low."

The reporting in the first post no way reflects the tone of the report
!

Edited 1 time. Last update at 23-Nov-2011

J2SkiNews
reply to 'Survey Finds 94% Of Experienced Skiers Don't Wear Helmets'
posted Nov-2011

Admin wrote:I think the words "Unbelievable" or "Flawed" need to be inserted at the beginning of this thread title Mr News Editor!

...sorry boss I just pulled out the most headline grabbing line. Now we're not allowed to phone hack anymore you have to allow me some journalistic traits, surely?
www  The Snow Hunter

Topic last updated on 26-November-2011 at 12:36