J2Ski logo J2Ski logo
Login Forum Search Recent Forums

Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders

Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders

Login
To Create or Answer a Topic

Started by J2SkiNews in Ski News - 6 Replies

Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders

J2SkiNews posted Jan-2016



A survey of over 1,000 skiers and snowboarders has found that a quarter of skiers obtain injuries compared to only 13% of snowboarders. Half of these injuries (52%) were considered to be 'not that serious', but over a third (38%) were rated as serious, and over half (58%) ended up going to hospital as a result of their injury. On average, skiers and snowboarders lost nearly two days of their holiday as a result of the injury they sustained.

The survey was carried out on behalf of London Bridge Hospital, which operates a dedicated Winter Ski Clinic throughout its specialist Orthopaedic departments. It is not known if it considered how many ski trips the skiers had been on on average compared to the snowboarder sample.

The survey also found that only half (52%) of skiers consider themselves to be a safe skier and, just 28% of snowboarders admit to being safe; as well as that less than two thirds (60%) wear a helmet when skiing and just over a third (36%) wear a helmet when snowboarding.

Mr Simon Owen-Johnstone, comments: "Helmets do not make you invincible - it is still possible to sustain a head injury despite wearing a helmet, but research points to the benefits and there is no reason or excuse not to wear one."

Mr Christopher Uff, Consultant Neurosurgeon at London Bridge Hospital adds, "All ski hire shops offer ski helmets with ski and boot hire. Some people may have a misguided view that wearing a helmet is not 'cool', but the consequences of a slip can be devastating. Without a helmet, any head injury you sustain will be far more severe than if you were wearing a helmet. A helmet could mean that you recover faster and make any physical or psychological disability less severe. Of course you can still get a head injury with a helmet, but you may just walk away from it with a badly damaged helmet and bruised ego."

Whilst winter sports holidays are a chance for adventure, Mr. Simon Owen-Johnstone, a Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon at London Bridge Hospital, urges people not to push themselves beyond their capabilities; "Every winter my clinics are full of injured skiers and boarders who have simply been too ambitious. Staying safe is all about being sensible. Making a realistic assessment of the environment, and your own abilities. If you're in a party, the least able sets the pace. Be ready to change plans, don't overestimate your ability, and don't be too proud to admit defeat."

In terms of the injuries sustained, Mr Simon Owen-Johnstone states "upper limb winter sports injuries are not as common as lower limb injuries. Sprains and strains are the most common, but after those the most likely are shoulder dislocations, collarbone fractures and disruptions of the acromio-clavicular joint, located at the end of the collarbone."

Commenting on the preparation for holidays Mr Simon Owen-Johnstone continues, "winter sport is hard athletic activity. It's not something you can do well after 51 weeks of inactivity. To enjoy it properly you'll need to have a level of fitness, and that needs to start at least six weeks before departure, preferably longer. Thigh and knee endurance is the most useful, but spine flexibility is important too.

"If you get injured, whether you have treatment abroad or not, you're likely to need ongoing care on return to the UK. Injuries take time to recover. Some injuries are not apparent until days or weeks later, so if you have symptoms when you're home they should really be checked out.

"The best advice I can give you is accept that your ten-year old is a better skier and don't try to keep up!" concludes Mr Simon Owen-Johnstone.

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents states that approximately 10,000 UK skiers and snowboarders are admitted to hospital every year with injuries following their winter-sports holidays.
www  The Snow Hunter

Admin
reply to 'Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders'
posted Jan-2016

Well, there's some sound advice there but the survey results look like nonsense...

survey wrote:a quarter of skiers obtain injuries ... and over half (58%) ended up going to hospital as a result of their injury.

So that's 15% of skiers get hospitalised for an average of "nearly two days"??? Over what time-period? Is that every season or over a lifetime of skiing? Just about believable if it's lifetime, but every other previous survey I've seen has indicated that boarders tend to suffer slightly more injuries (wrists being the main additional vulnerability IIRC).

survey wrote:only half (52%) of skiers consider themselves to be a safe skier and, just 28% of snowboarders admit to being safe;

Seriously? 72% of snowboarders think they're dangerous - or they're just not sure if they're safe? I'd expect skiers to be quite like drivers; in that just about everyone thinks they're better than average... 8)

survey wrote:less than two thirds (60%) wear a helmet when skiing and just over a third (36%) wear a helmet when snowboarding.

Is the survey 10 years old??? Although proportions are less among our European friends, percentages for helmet-wearing Brits must be around 90% of skiers and probably 95% of snowboarders.

some chap wrote:"The best advice I can give you is accept that your ten-year old is a better skier and don't try to keep up!"

No, I really don't think that's the best advice you can give us. :roll: Your average ten-year-old has slightly less than no fear whatsoever and will travel as fast as they can get away with... Teaching them to ski with (and wait for, if necessary) their parents and buddies forms good habits and helps them develop the empathy and awareness of those around them they need.

J2SkiNews wrote:A survey of over 1,000 skiers and snowboarders

Where did they find them? The lidless nutters ski club?? :lol:
The Admin Man

Andyoneil
reply to 'Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders'
posted Jan-2016

I was about to pen something similar but was busy ranting on another thread (also connected to helmets)

Adders has beaten me to it though

This reminds me that 73% of statistics are made up on the spot.....

J2SkiNews
reply to 'Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders'
posted Jan-2016

Well I am disappointed to see these clearly bullet proof numbers ;) challenged, this must be the first time in history that a survey carried out on behalf of a PR agency has turned out numbers that some may dispute, but I had asked the time period question and have now got the answer,

"According to the survey results, the skiers who answered our survey have been skiing an average of 5.2 times. The snowboarders who answered our survey have been an average 4.7 times so there really isn't much discrepancy here."
www  The Snow Hunter

Andyoneil
reply to 'Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders'
posted Jan-2016

Boarders who have been more than once (never mind 5ish) and two thirds of them don't wear a lid???

Never caught a back edge then.....

Ranchero_1979
reply to 'Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders'
posted Jan-2016

Just back from big days touring >800m uphill and >3000m downhill. Snow conditions were so so variable, from wind blown hard pack, to breakable crust. Only a very small sweet spot of North facing 2800m seemed to exist. Can definitely see how boarders are less likely to suffer lower limb injuries, particularly knee injuries in current conditions. Of course you never really know what to expect but definitely some snap city snow out there at moment.

Andymol2
reply to 'Skiers More Likely to be Injured Than Boarders'
posted Jan-2016

That's interesting - the figures I've come across in medical journals where they have used A&E and medical centre number rather than questionnaires suggested similar rates of injury for both boarders and skiers with the exception of upper limb trauma which was roughly double in boarders and ACL injuries were slightly less frequent in boarders.

It may be a simplistic interpretation as self reporting of injuries is a little subjective and would need to be corrected for age and sex and nature of skiing.
Andy M

Topic last updated on 28-January-2016 at 11:00